saudi arabia turkey and leadership
Monday 17 February 2025
Last Updated : GMT 09:07:40
Egypt Today, egypt today

Saudi Arabia, Turkey and leadership

Egypt Today, egypt today

saudi arabia turkey and leadership

Abdul Rahman Al-Rashid

Leadership is an old and continuous tale in the media’s imagination but leadership is a result and not a decision. Even before the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, there has been talk about competition over leadership. So is it truth or illusion, and what are its standards?

The concept of leadership in the Middle East includes plenty of imagination that’s cloned from the eras of empires and most of it is political and propagandist. There are standards in measuring the concept of power – there is the superpower, which is the US and the great power like Russia, China and the EU. It’s measured by military, economic, technological and cultural superiority and not just nuclear power or media exaggerations. 

If we want to implement these standards in our region, we will realize there is a group of regional powers and not a single one that is superior. For example, military superiority alone is not enough. Israel is the strongest military and technological regional power but its area is small and besieged and it’s not a regional economic power.

ALSO READ: What next after Netanyahu’s visit to Muscat? 

Turkey’s area is large and it is a member in the NATO but like Iran it does not have the same language as the region’s countries and it has geopolitical restrictions that limits its influence, as we’ve seen its incapability in Syria’s war.

Iran is large and ambitious to assume leadership, and it has relied on power for 40 years. Today it’s a spreading power but it is the poorest country in the region. There are many heads in the Middle East and not a single leader and not a single leading nation.

The dream of leadership is what destroyed late Egyptian President Gamal Abdelnasser and his project in one single test, the 1967 War, because it was a leadership that was built on propaganda.

Power elements
What about Turkey and Saudi Arabia? Both countries have power elements: area, population, geography, massive resources, domestic stability and strength of the political regime. Despite that, I do not think there is a possibility of acceptance of the claim of supremacy and leadership in the region.

As for the Muslims’ leadership in the world, then this is a metaphorical expression. Spiritually, Saudi Arabia is the leader because it is where there are holy sites, which one billion Muslims visit for Hajj and where the qibla, the direction that should be faced when praying, are located. Turkey does not have anything sacred for Muslims. 

On the economic level, Saudi Arabia is more influential. Turkey tried to be an economic power so it expanded from Iraq’s Kurdistan to Libya but it lost its investments in the Arab Spring wars.

It’s now trying to militarily expand at the expense of Qatar in the Red Sea and the Gulf, but we know this is a temporary situation and after few years, Doha will lapse after spending its savings and Turkey will withdraw. Saudi Arabia has politically tried to build fronts but it also suffered and was incapable of uniting the ranks of the group that supports it.

Unlike Iran and Turkey, the Saudi foreign policy is based on a defensive and not an offensive concept. It builds a complicated network of alliances and via several means, such as the alliance of war in Yemen, an alliance to confront Saddam following his invasion of Kuwait and an alliance to confront Iran today.

Regional leadership
I think no regional power can achieve leadership no matter how armed to the teeth it is and no matter how hungry it is for power and expansion, like Iran is. The cost is very high and it may cause the collapse of the state.

This is what happened to the regime of Saddam Hussein who was obsessed with power and leadership. Saddam spent all his years in power and losing wars. Hence, bets on the region’s leadership are nothing more than media fabrications or ignorant ambitions. 

Apart from what is being written in the media, there is no real Turkish-Saudi competition over leadership. There is competition over some issues and consensus over other issues, temporarily and pending the interactions of the Khashoggi case. This is what Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman meant when he said someone was trying to create a rift with Turkey.

Riyadh’s policy is defensive to protect its borders and its regional surrounding and is not competitive with Turkey. This explains why most of Riyadh’s focus is directed toward confronting Iran in hopes the latter’s regime abandons its hostile and expansive policy or it is besieged and its threats on the kingdom and the region are diminished.

Real leadership is a final result and not a presidential decision, and it’s reflected by the state’s capability of economic, scientific, technological, industrial, military, cultural and diplomatic supremacy.

No country can succeed alone if its successes do not also reach the region. And as the prince said: Dubai is a model, and Saudi Arabia or Egypt lift the entire region.  Leaderships will thus remain media legends.

From :Alarabiya

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

saudi arabia turkey and leadership saudi arabia turkey and leadership



GMT 15:03 2013 Monday ,15 April

Pegasus Airlines to go for IPO

GMT 08:31 2017 Tuesday ,29 August

MKs storm into Aqsa mosque under tight security

GMT 08:24 2017 Wednesday ,21 June

UN official reveals challenges

GMT 05:21 2015 Sunday ,15 February

4 keys to overcoming losses

GMT 10:06 2012 Tuesday ,29 May

Dormice use whiskers to climb

GMT 06:28 2012 Saturday ,28 April

Egyptian giants lead away charge

GMT 15:46 2018 Monday ,10 September

Oppo launches its premium smartphone Find X in UAE

GMT 17:12 2017 Friday ,31 March

Bahraini-Swiss relations lauded

GMT 14:16 2015 Tuesday ,24 February

Jordan King holds talks with emir of Kuwait

GMT 18:31 2017 Wednesday ,09 August

Powerful earthquake in China, hundreds injured

GMT 06:43 2017 Monday ,24 April

Ibrahim Mahmud Meets Wali of East Darfur

GMT 07:46 2013 Tuesday ,26 March

7 killed in road mishap in eastern Pakistan

GMT 06:07 2015 Friday ,03 July

‘James Bond’ Bentley up for auction

GMT 21:36 2015 Tuesday ,04 August

Militants kill local official in Southern Somalia

GMT 23:13 2015 Tuesday ,16 June

At least 2 soldiers killed in Mogadishu blast

GMT 10:42 2016 Tuesday ,26 January

Oscars diversity row 'legitimate'
 
 Egypt Today Facebook,egypt today facebook  Egypt Today Twitter,egypt today twitter Egypt Today Rss,egypt today rss  Egypt Today Youtube,egypt today youtube  Egypt Today Youtube,egypt today youtube

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2021 ©

Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2021 ©

egypttoday egypttoday egypttoday egypttoday
egypttoday egypttoday egypttoday
egypttoday
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
egypttoday, Egypttoday, Egypttoday